Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutPLN 18-25 Report to Planning & Development Committee Report Number: PLN 18-25 Date: October 6, 2025 From: Kyle Bentley Director, City Development & CBO Subject: City of Pickering 2024 Annual Housing Monitoring Report File: D-1300-016 Recommendation: 1. That Report PLN 18-25, regarding the City of Pickering 2024 Annual Housing Monitoring Report, be received for information. Executive Summary: The purpose of this report is twofold: to provide an update to Council on the progress in implementing the Action Items of the Pickering Housing Strategy & Action Plan (see Attachment 1); and to report back on tracking affordable and rental housing, including existing approved, and/or pending private rental apartment buildings, in accordance with Resolution #956/22. Relationship to the Pickering Strategic Plan: The recommendations in this report respond to the Pickering Strategic Plan Priorities of Advocate for an Inclusive, Welcoming, Safe & Healthy Community; Advance Innovation & Responsible Planning to Support a Connected, Well-Serviced Community; and Foster an Engaged & Informed Community. Financial Implications: The recommendations of this report do not present any financial implications to the City. Discussion: The purpose of this report is to provide Council an update on the progress in implementing the Action Items of the Pickering Housing Strategy & Action Plan; and to report back on annual tracking of affordable and rental housing within the City. 1. Background The Pickering Housing Strategy & Action Plan, 2021-2031, (Housing Strategy) was approved on January 24, 2022, by Resolution #790/22. Action Item 3.7 in the Housing Strategy aims to establish an annual monitoring report to describe how well the City is meeting its housing needs. Subsequently, on June 30, 2022, Council passed Resolution #956/22, requesting staff’s reporting in accordance with Action Item 3.7 to also include tracking of affordable and rental housing, including existing, approved, and/or pending private rental apartment buildings. PLN 18-25 October 6, 2025 Page 2 The second annual housing monitoring report (PLN 02-25) was presented to Council in January 2025, which reported on housing statistics up to the end of December 2023, and staff’s efforts in addressing the Housing Strategy Action Items up to the end of December 2024 (Resolution #650/25). This is the third annual housing monitoring report, which contains statistics on affordable housing and rental housing and other relevant metrics monitored to the end of December 2024, and staff’s efforts in addressing the Housing Strategy Action Items to the end of June 2025. 2.Housing Strategy Action Item Monitoring Since the previous annual housing report in January 2025, staff have completed one additional Action Item. A total of four Action Items have been completed since the approval of the Pickering Housing Strategy & Action Plan in 2022. Four Action Items were eliminated due to recent legislative changes or were deemed unfeasible through further research. Staff are currently working on 14 other Action Items. Attachment 1 to this report provides an update on the status of the Action Items to the end of June 2025. 2.1. Completion of Action Item 1.12 (Requiring an Affordability and Accessibility Analysis as part of a complete application for residential developments) Action Item 1.12 recommended an Official Plan policy requiring the submission of an Affordability and Accessibility Analysis as part of a complete application for residential development. The intent of this Action Item is to monitor the availability and provision of affordable and accessible housing in new developments to provide the City with baseline data to inform how the City’s affordable housing targets are being met. A similar policy was included in Official Plan Amendment 38 (OPA 38), which required an Affordable Housing Brief as a part of the complete application. OPA 38 was approved by the Ontario Land Tribunal in December 2024, implementing this policy in the City’s Official Plan. An affordable housing brief is now a required study for Official Plan Amendment, Zoning By-law Amendment, Draft Plan of Subdivision, and Draft Plan of Condominium Approvals. 2.2. Action Items being addressed through the Pickering Official Plan Review (Action Items 1.1, 1.2, 1.3, 1.5, 1.6, 1.7, 1.10, and 1.11) A number of Action Items within the Housing Strategy are policy-based items to be added to the City’s Official Plan. These items are currently being reviewed and addressed through the City’s Official Plan Review process, “Pickering Forward”. Below is a summary of the Action Items being addressed through Pickering Forward: •Item 1.1: Add a definition for “affordable housing” •Item 1.2: Add a definition for “housing options” PLN 18-25 October 6, 2025 Page 3 • Item 1.3: Require the municipality to maintain the ability to accommodate residential growth for a minimum of 15 years • Item 1.5: New policy to protect existing rental housing stock from conversion • Item 1.6: New policy to prohibit the demolition of existing rental housing units • Item 1.7: New policies to implement “inclusionary zoning” in Major Transit Station Areas • Item 1.10: Consider removing or reducing the minimum requirement for parking spaces for affordable housing and/or supportive housing, and allowing alternative parking space options • Item 1.11: Discourage “down zoning” high and medium density residential designations to lower density residential designations Staff have recently concluded Phase 1 of the Pickering Forward project, Background and Research. This Phase of the project involved extensive community engagement on various topics, including Housing and Affordability. Through Phase 2 (currently underway), staff will review the Action Items listed above, along with community feedback, to inform the development of policies in the new Official Plan to help address housing options, affordability, and accessibility within Pickering. 3. Tracking Rental Housing The private rental market consists of the primary rental market (often referred to as purpose-built rental buildings), and the secondary rental market (units not purposely built for the rental market, but currently being rented out). The Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) conducts annual Rental Market Surveys, reporting data on various metrics in the primary rental market. The Urban Rental Market Survey reports on the number of units in primary rental buildings (containing at least three rental units), which have been on the market for at least three months. While the most recent survey data reported data up to the end of 2023, the City’s AMANDA database fills in the gaps by providing information data on approved building permits. The new purpose-built rental building at 1475 Whites Road, known as Fourteen75, was completed and granted full occupancy in 2024. The addition of this building increased the number of primary rental units in Pickering to 580 units, compared to 353 units recorded at the end of 2023. The project also included a number of 1 bedroom and 2 bedroom units, which increased the provision of smaller apartment units in the primary rental market. The chart below shows the unit breakdown in the primary rental market in 2024 compared to 2023. PLN 18-25 October 6, 2025 Page 4 Source: CMHC Urban Rental Market Survey, 2023; and City of Pickering, AMANDA Database, 2024. 3.1 Primary Rental Market Rents CMHC’s annual Rental Market Survey reports on average rents in the primary rental market across Canada. The following table displays the average consolidated rent by unit type for the Pickering/Ajax/Uxbridge area. Year 1 Bedroom 2 Bedrooms 3 Bedrooms 2018 $ 953 $1,248 $1,397 2019 $ 982 $1,237 $1,489 2020 $1,198 $1,362 $1,506 2021 $ 965 $1,302 $1,563 2022 $1,193 $1,533 $1,608 2023 $1,400 $1,805 $2,006 2024 $1,264 $1,664 $1,777 Source: CMHC Rental Market Survey, 2024. Average rents for all unit types have come down compared to the previous year, but remains higher than the previous years. This modest decrease reflects the general observations in rental markets across the Greater Toronto Area. 343 3 6 1 362 139 78 10 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 3+ Bedrooms 2 Bedroom 1 Bedroom Bachelor Studios Pickering's Primary Rental Market Unit By Size (2023 vs. 2024) 2023 2024 PLN 18-25 October 6, 2025 Page 5 3.2 Vacancy Rate for Primary Rental Units According to CMHC, a vacancy rate of 3.0 percent is identified as a healthy vacancy rate, representing a balance between rental housing supply and demand. A unit is considered vacant if it is physically unoccupied and available for immediate rental at the time of the survey. Vacancy rates are based on the CMHC Rental Market Survey, which reports on a consolidated vacancy rate for Pickering, Ajax, and Uxbridge (Zone 28). In 2024, the total apartment vacancy rate (considering all unit types) in Zone 28 was 1.0 percent. This is a slight increase from the previous year of 0.9 percent. However, the vacancy rate remains low compared to a healthy rate of 3.0 percent. Looking at the vacancy rate of 3 bedroom units, the vacancy rate in Zone 28 remains very low at a rate of 0.4 percent. Low vacancy rates indicate high demands for purpose-built rental housing in Pickering, particularly for larger family-sized units, such as 3 bedroom units, which have remained under 1.0% since 2022. 3.3 Additional Dwelling Units (ADUs) The chart below illustrates that 1,044 ADUs were registered in Pickering from 2005 to the end of 2024. These units may, in part, be contributing towards Pickering’s affordable rental housing stock, depending on whether or not the units are being rented out by homeowners. Source: City of Pickering, AMANDA Database, 2024. 4. Residential Building Permit and Development Application Activity In 2024, staff received 1,819 building permit applications for the construction of 2,089 new residential units. Permits were issued for constructing a total of 1,545 residential units, comprising 564 apartments, 589 single and semi-detached dwellings, and 392 townhouses. 57 31 20 36 28 33 32 58 65 57 58 66 47 46 43 38 49 71 86 123 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 20 0 5 20 0 6 20 0 7 20 0 8 20 0 9 20 1 0 20 1 1 20 1 2 20 1 3 20 1 4 20 1 5 20 1 6 20 1 7 20 1 8 20 1 9 20 2 0 20 2 1 20 2 2 20 2 3 20 2 4 Registered Additional Dwelling Units (ADUs) - Pickering PLN 18-25 October 6, 2025 Page 6 The chart below illustrates the percentage of units by dwelling type for which building permits were issued in 2024 compared to previous years. The distribution of dwelling types in the building permits issued in 2024 remains relatively consistent compared to 2023. Source: City of Pickering, AMANDA Database, 2024 Looking at the development pipeline, the chart below shows the percentage of units by dwelling type that have been approved in 2024 through registered Plan of Subdivisions or Site Plan and are ready to apply for building permits, compared to previous years1. Source: City of Pickering, AMANDA Database, 2024 1 Data in this chart does not include the number of residential units in a high density block approved through a Plan of Subdivision, as the number of units may change through the Site Plan process. 65% 23%21%35% 58% 28% 55% 33%38% 35% 77% 59% 65% 42% 49% 45% 26%25% 20%22% 41%37% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2016-2024 Shares of Unit by Dwelling Type Issued by Building Permits Singles and Semi Townhouse Apartments 43% 2% 40% 21%28%31%44%52% 25% 57% 20% 42% 31%28% 28% 40% 71%78% 19% 79% 40%40%28% 8%4% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2016-2024 Shares of Unit by Dwelling Type in Registered Subdivisions and Approved Site Plans Singles and Semi Townhouse Apartments PLN 18-25 October 6, 2025 Page 7 5. Tracking Affordable Housing Developments The five affordable housing developments that have been proposed, approved, or completed since the adoption of the Housing Strategy & Action Plan, 2022 are listed in Attachment 2. Proposals or developments that have made progress in 2024 are highlighted below: 5.1 Tribute Lands at the northwest corner of Highway 401 and Liverpool Road This development is a multi-phased development consisting of three mixed-use towers with a total of 1,779 total residential units, and 1,155 square metres of commercial/retail space spread out within ground levels of the podiums. Of the approved residential units, 27 units are provided to Habitat for Humanity GTA to be sold at an affordable rate to low-income families. Significant progress has been made as of the end of 2024. Site plan approval was issued for the first two phases of the development, which consists of 1,176 residential units and 582 square metres of commercial/retail space. The 27 affordable housing units have been confirmed to be in the first two phases of the development through a letter of intent from Habitat for Humanity GTA. Construction for the foundation and below-grade structures are currently underway. Occupancies for the first two phases are anticipated within the next five years. 5.2 1515 Pickering Parkway This site is zoned to permit the development of a 40-storey condominium apartment building, with a podium ranging between 4 and 6 storeys. The developer has partnered up Habitat for Humanity GTA to provide 1 affordable unit within the development. The proposed development is progressing through final stages of site plan approval, and the development is currently being marketed. 6. Affordable Residential Units Bulletin In 2023, the Province introduced new definitions of “affordable housing” in the Development Charges Act, based on local incomes and market conditions, to calculate development charges. The Province issued the Affordable Residential Units Bulletin the following year that set out the average purchase prices, market rents, and income-based thresholds for municipalities with respect to affordability. The figures from the Bulletin are to be used to determine the eligibility of a residential unit for an exemption from development charges, the maximum community benefits charge, and parkland dedication requirements. The first bulletin came into effect on June 1, 2024, and it has since been replaced by a new bulletin, effective August 1, 2025. A summary chart of Pickering’s Bulletin is contained in Attachment 3. PLN 18-25 October 6, 2025 Page 8 7. Legislative Changes Affecting Affordable Housing Since the previous Annual Housing Monitoring report in January 2025, there have been various changes to Provincial legislation that impact the planning, approval, and construction of affordable housing in Ontario. Bill 17 received royal assent on June 5, 2025, changing both the Planning Act and Development Charges Act. Additionally, Bill 17 amended the Inclusionary Zoning Regulations (O. Reg. 232/18), to cap the affordable housing units in developments within a Protected Major Transit Station Area (PMTSA) at 5%, and to limit the period of affordability to a maximum of 25 years. This change, initially introduced through Bill 23, has eliminated the ability for municipalities to mandate a higher percentage of units within a PMTSA to be affordable. This directly impacts Action Item 1.7 in the Housing Strategy to consider adding new Official Plan policies to implement inclusionary zoning in Pickering’s PMTSA. Durham Region has completed a high-level Assessment Report for inclusionary zoning in various PMTSAs in the region, including the Pickering GO PMTSA. In order for the City to introduce an inclusionary zoning framework in the Official Plan, the City must first delineate the PMTSA boundaries within the City’s Official Plan. Additionally, the City must complete a scoped assessment report in accordance with provincial regulations that analyze local demographics, incomes, market pricing, housing supply, and other factors to determine the affordable housing need in the community. Due to the current downturn in the housing market, staff are of the opinion that the scoped inclusionary zoning assessment may not support the implementation of an inclusionary zoning framework in the PMTSA at this time. Through the Pickering Forward process, staff will delineate the PMTSA boundaries in the Official Plan and consider policies to enable inclusionary zoning to occur in the PMTSA in the future. 8. Conclusion This report outlines the actions taken by the City since the previous Annual Housing Monitoring Report, presents updates on the City’s affordable and rental housing developments, and provides other housing statistics related to housing affordability in Pickering. Attachments: 1. Pickering Housing Strategy Action Item Update 2. Pickering Affordable Housing Development Tracking 3. Affordable Residential Units Bulletin PLN 18-25 October 6, 2025 Page 9 Prepared By: Original Signed By Ziya Cao (Acting) Senior Planner, Policy & Housing Original Signed By Déan Jacobs, MCIP, RPP Manager, Policy & Geomatics Approved/Endorsed By: Original Signed By Catherine Rose, MCIP, RPP Chief Planner Original Signed By Kyle Bentley, P. Eng. Director, City Development & CBO ZC:ld Recommended for the consideration of Pickering City Council Original Signed By R. Holborn Marisa Carpino, M.A. Chief Administrative Officer for: Action Item Update – Annual Housing Monitoring Report – June 2025 Attachment 1 to Report PLN 18-25 Pickering Housing Strategy Action Plan Each action is categorized according to the following themes: policy, financial incentives, and other. A timeframe and estimated cost of implementation has been identified for each action and is shown in the table below. In addition, the table identifies the gap from the Phase 1: Research and Gap Analysis Report, March 31, 2021, that the action addresses and the City department to lead the initiative. Gaps Identified through the Research and Gap Analysis Report, March 31, 2021. •Gap 1 relates to the need for housing options for: •Low and moderate income earners •Rental and ownership housing •Range of unit sizes, and •Accessible units •Gap 3 relates to the need for: •Home ownership housing options for moderate income earners •Range of unit sizes, and •Accessible units •Gap 2 relates to the need for: •Primary rental market units of all sizes •Protection of units in the primary rental market •Accessible units in the primary rental market •Gap 4 are policy gaps related to housing in the City’s Official Plan that are the result of new or recent changes to provincial legislation. Legend for updated Action Plan below: Timeframe Short-term ■□□1-5 years Medium-term □■□5-10 years Long-term □□■10 or more years Cost Estimate Low $ Under $10,000 Medium $$ $10,000-$25,000 High $$$ Over $25,000 Status Update Ongoing In Progress/ Currently Being Reviewed Completed/ No Longer Required Action Item Update – Annual Housing Monitoring Report – June 2025 Action Gap # Addressed Lead Department Initial Time Frame New Time Frame Cost Status Update 1.0 Policy 1.1 Add a definition of “affordable housing” to the City’s Official Plan, which includes reference to the average purchase price and average market rent in accordance with the definition in the Provincial Policy Statement, 2020 Note: The Provincial Policy Statement 2020 has been replaced by the Provincial Planning Statement 2024 (PPS). Gap 4 City Development ■□□ ■□□ $ In Progress The definition will be included through the City Official Plan Review process, currently underway. 1.2 Add a definition of “Housing Options” to the City’s Official Plan. Gap 4 City Development ■□□ ■□□ $ In Progress Both the approved Regional Official Plan (ROP) and recently released Provincial Planning Statement 2024 (PPS 2024) contain a definition of housing options. The definition will be included through the City Official Plan Review process. Action Item Update – Annual Housing Monitoring Report – June 2025 Action Gap # Addressed Lead Department Initial Time Frame New Time Frame Cost Status Update 1.3 Amend the City’s Official Plan to reflect the Provincial Policy Statement 2020 requirement for the municipality to maintain the ability to accommodate residential growth for a minimum of 15 years (as opposed to 10 years as currently written). Note: The Provincial Policy Statement 2020 has been replaced by the Provincial Planning Statement 2024 (PPS). Gap 4 City Development ■□□ ■□□ $ In Progress The PPS 2024 states that municipalities shall maintain, at all times, the ability to accommodate residential growth for a minimum of 15 years through lands which are designated and available for residential development. The recently approved ROP states the timeframe is a minimum of 15-years through lands which are designated and available to accommodate residential growth. This action item will be implemented through the City Official Plan Review process. Action Item Update – Annual Housing Monitoring Report – June 2025 Action Gap # Addressed Lead Department Initial Time Frame New Time Frame Cost Status Update 1.4 Consider amending the City’s Official Plan to reflect the Provincial Policy Statement 2020 option to increase from 3 to 5 years the minimum number of years to accommodate a short- term supply of residential lands, subject to the outcome of Durham Region’s Envision Durham exercise. Note: The Provincial Policy Statement 2020 has been replaced by the Provincial Planning Statement 2024 (PPS). Gap 4 City Development ■□□ ■□□ $ No Longer Required The recently approved PPS 2024 removed the options for upper- tier municipalities to increase the minimum years to accommodate a short-term supply of residential lands. Envision Durham did not stipulate an increase in the approved plans, as such this Action Item is no longer required. 1.5 Add new official plan policy to protect existing rental housing stock from conversion. Gap 4 City Development ■□□ ■□□ $ In Progress This action item will be implemented through the City’s Official Plan Review process. Staff are monitoring the changes to the Municipal Act that permit the Minister to make regulations imposing limits and conditions on the powers of a local municipality to prohibit and regulate the demolition and conversion of residential rental properties. There is currently no timeline available for when the Minister may introduce the regulations. Action Item Update – Annual Housing Monitoring Report – June 2025 Action Gap # Addressed Lead Department Initial Time Frame New Time Frame Cost Status Update 1.6 Add new Official Plan policy which prohibits the demolition of existing rental housing units unless the proposed redevelopment meets specified conditions. Gap 4 City Development ■□□ ■□□ $ In Progress This action item will be implemented through the City’s Official Plan Review process. Staff are monitoring the changes to the Municipal Act that permit the Minister to make regulations imposing limits and conditions on the powers of a local municipality to prohibit and regulate the demolition and conversion of residential rental properties. There is currently no timeline for when the Minister may introduce the regulations. Action Item Update – Annual Housing Monitoring Report – June 2025 Action Gap # Addressed Lead Department Initial Time Frame New Time Frame Cost Status Update 1.7 Consider adding new Official Plan policies to implement “inclusionary zoning” in Major Transit Station Areas, following Durham Region’s completion of the “Assessment Report”. Note: the “Assessment Report” refers to an assessment report for inclusionary zoning, and not a housing assessment report, which describes the current and future housing needs of a municipality or community. Gap 4 City Development ■■□ ■■□ $ Currently Being Reviewed Durham has completed a Regional Assessment Report for Inclusionary Zoning. The City must delineate the boundaries of the Protected Major Transit Station Area (PMTSA) within the City’s Official Plan and complete a scoped inclusionary zoning assessment before an inclusionary zoning framework can be implemented in the Official Plan. The PMTSA boundaries will be delineated through the Official Plan Review process. However, with the downturn in the current housing market, Staff will defer undertaking the scoped assessment report to a time when market conditions are more robust. Action Item Update – Annual Housing Monitoring Report – June 2025 Action Gap # Addressed Lead Department Initial Time Frame New Time Frame Cost Status Update 1.8 Additional Dwelling Units: (a) Review and update the City zoning by-laws and Two- Dwelling Unit By-law to reflect the More Homes, More Choice Act changes to permit Additional Dwelling Units in a detached, semi-detached or townhouse as well as in a building or structure ancillary to a detached house, semi- detached or townhouse. (b) Consider allowing Additional Dwelling Units in rural areas subject to the capacity of well and septic systems. (c) Consider reducing or removing the City’s parking requirement for Additional Dwelling Units located in areas well served by transit. (d) Examine other existing zoning requirements that may present barriers to increasing Additional Dwelling Units within the City. Gaps 2, 4 City Development, Corporate Services (Municipal Law Enforcement) ■■□ ■□□ $ Completed 2024 Project Website: https://www.pickering.ca/en/city- hall/additional-dwelling- units.aspx Council approved amendments to the City’s zoning by-laws in September 2024 to permit ADU’s in accordance with the Planning Act. Also, a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) between Pickering and Whitby has been entered into for the sharing of resources to prepare pre- approved building drawings, for detached ADUs. This program aims to streamline design selection and building permits for detached ADUs. Action Item Update – Annual Housing Monitoring Report – June 2025 Action Gap # Addressed Lead Department Initial Time Frame New Time Frame Cost Status Update 1.9 Ensure that the City’s Official Plan policies and zoning regulations do not present barriers to shared living (co-housing, co-living) arrangements in appropriate areas as-of-right. Gaps 1-3 City Development ■□□ $ Completed 2022 Staff completed a review and established that there are no barriers to shared living arrangements in the policies of the Pickering Official Plan. 1.10 Consider removing or reducing the minimum requirement for parking spaces for affordable housing and/or supportive housing and allowing developers to propose alternative parking space options. Gap 4 City Development ■□□ ■□□ $ In Progress Recent changes to the Planning Act removed the ability of municipalities to impose minimum parking requirements in Protected Major Transit Station Areas (PMTSA). Policies regarding minimum parking requirements for areas outside PMTSA’s will be analyzed through the current Official Plan review process. 1.11 Consider discouraging “down zoning” high and medium density residential designations to lower density residential designations. Gap 4 City Development ■□□ ■□□ $ In Progress The inclusion of policies discouraging ”down zoning” will be considered through the current Official Plan review. Action Item Update – Annual Housing Monitoring Report – June 2025 Action Gap # Addressed Lead Department Initial Time Frame New Time Frame Cost Status Update 1.12 Add an Official Plan policy requiring the submission of an Affordability and Accessibility Analysis as part of a complete application for residential development, subject to criteria. Gaps 1-3 City Development ■□□ ■□□ $ Completed 2025 This Action Item is completed through the approval of OPA 38 by the Ontario Land Tribunal (OLT). An affordable housing brief is now a required study for Official Plan Amendment, Zoning By-law Amendment, Draft Plan of Subdivision, and Draft Plan of Condominium Approvals. Note: OPA 38 was approved in part. Site-specific appeals to OPA 38 remain before the Tribunal. 2.0 Financial Incentives 2.1 Consider establishing a corporate policy whereby surplus or underutilized City-owned lands or buildings that are not required for municipal purposes, such as for parkland, are first considered for development of affordable rental housing. Gaps 1-3 Corporate Services, Finance and City Development ■■□ ■■□ $$ - $$$ Work Has Not Commenced Action Item Update – Annual Housing Monitoring Report – June 2025 Action Gap # Addressed Lead Department Initial Time Frame New Time Frame Cost Status Update 2.2 Consider waiving fees or providing a grant equivalent to certain development application fees, development charges, property taxes, and/or parkland dedication requirements, for affordable rental, affordable ownership, and/or supportive housing developments on a case- by-case basis. Gaps 1-3 Finance □■□ □■■ $$ - $$$ No longer required Action no longer required due to the introduction of Bill 23 that has provided financial relief to some degree for affordable units. The loss of DC fee revenues is now funded by casino funds. Bill 23 had a direct impact on the action item as the Province provided exemptions or reductions to development charges (DC’s) as-of-right. Affordable units are exempt from paying DC’s and parkland dedications. Rental units have reduced DC rates based on the number of bedrooms. 2.3 Prioritize and facilitate approvals for projects which provide affordable rental, affordable ownership, supportive housing, and purpose-built rental housing units. Gaps 1-3 City Development, Engineering, Fire ■□□ ■□□ $ Ongoing Currently, applications that include affordable or rental units are prioritized and streamlined on an ad hoc basis. 2.4 Consider establishing a Housing Reserve Fund which can be funded through a special levy and/or Community Benefit Charge. Gaps 1-3 Finance □■■ □■■ $ No longer required This action item is no longer required due to the introduction of Bill 23. Action Item Update – Annual Housing Monitoring Report – June 2025 Action Gap # Addressed Lead Department Initial Time Frame New Time Frame Cost Status Update 2.5 Consider undertaking a feasibility study for a Vacant Home Tax. Gaps 1-3 Finance □■□ □■□ $ Action not to be implemented The introduction of a vacant home tax requires administration support and corresponding financial resources. The benefits are questionable when measured against the cost to implement the program. The actual number of vacant homes is often much smaller than initially believed. In Toronto, only 2,100 properties were declared empty out of 775,000 declarations which represents a vacancy rate of approximately 3/10’s of one percent. 3.0 Other 3.1 Encourage developers to consider designing flexible spaces that can accommodate shared living or multi-generational living. Gaps 1, 3 City Development ■□□ ■□□ $ Ongoing Through pre-consultation meetings and preliminary discussions, staff are encouraging developers to consider designing flexible spaces. Action Item Update – Annual Housing Monitoring Report – June 2025 Action Gap # Addressed Lead Department Initial Time Frame New Time Frame Cost Status Update 3.2 Consider connecting interested developers with experts or consultants in the field of management, and operation, of affordable, rental housing. Gaps 2 Economic Development, City Development ■□□ ■□□ $ Ongoing Staff continue to network to confirm opportunities to connect the development community with experts in affordable and rental housing. In May 2024, a new City policy, and a formalized registration process, was approved to better profile and support local ratepayer associations, which offers direct communication to each association regarding Council and Committee meetings. 3.3 Provide guidance to developers, not-for-profits and other proponents of affordable rental, affordable ownership and/or supportive housing, on the planning and building approvals processes. Gaps 1-3 City Development ■□□ ■□□ $ Ongoing Staff provides guidance through preliminary discussions regarding the City‘s Housing Strategy, and through formal pre-consultation comments. Staff will continue to review what information packages can be created to further assist, and educate, proponents in the planning and building approval process. Action Item Update – Annual Housing Monitoring Report – June 2025 Action Gap # Addressed Lead Department Initial Time Frame New Time Frame Cost Status Update 3.4 Share information with developers about funding and other incentives available to address the City’s housing needs. Gaps 1-3 City Development ■□□ ■□□ $ Ongoing The City’s website includes a weblink to Durham Housing information. See: Affordable and Emergency Housing - City of Pickering City Development staff participates in a Durham Region Working Group tasked with investigating updating policies regarding exemptions for affordable housing proposals. 3.5 Consider advocating for the Province to establish a minimum number of accessible units or a percentage of accessible units for major residential development. Gaps 1-3 Corporate Communications ■□□ ■□□ $ Work Has Not Commenced 3.6 Consider advocating for the school boards to reduce, waive and/or defer their portion of Development Charges for affordable rental housing. Gaps 1, 2 Corporate Communications ■□□ ■□□ $ Work Has Not Commenced Action Item Update – Annual Housing Monitoring Report – June 2025 Action Gap # Addressed Lead Department Initial Time Frame New Time Frame Cost Status Update 3.7 Establish a Monitoring Plan that will annually update and review the baseline data set established in the Research and Gap Analysis Report, March 31, 2021, to ensure goals and objectives of the Housing Strategy are being met. Gaps 1-4 City Development ■□□ ■■■ $ Ongoing Staff are continuously working with Regional and Provincial partners to understand what data sources can be monitored and the most effective means of reporting the data. Monitoring will include tracking affordable and rental housing including existing, proposed, and approved applications. (as per Council Resolution #956/22). 3.8 To consider adding a dedicated function, similar to an Office of Affordability, within the City, the scope of work which would include being responsible for implementing the Pickering Housing Strategy & Action Plan 2021-2031, December 22, 2021. Gaps 1-4 City Development $$$ Completed 2024 The role of Senior Planner, Housing is currently filled in an acting capacity. A new cost centre for an Office of Affordability, in the City Development Department, was established through the 2024 Budget process. Attachment 2 to Report PLN 18-25 Pickering Affordable Housing Development Tracking Applicant Address Proposal Status Trillium Housing Oak Non-Profit Corporation 2635 William Jackson Drive A residential condominium development consisting of 216 stacked units. Of the built units, 38 units have been sold to purchasers who qualify for a no- payment Trillium Mortgage, which creates deeper affordability. Completed Tribute (Liverpool) Limited Northwest corner of Highway 401 and Liverpool Road Three residential towers with heights of 46, 49, and 53 storeys, consisting of 1,779 units residential units and 1,155 square metres of commercial space at grade. Of the proposed units, 27 units will be offered through Habitat for Humanity GTA as affordable housing units. Under Construction Pickering Valley Developments Inc. 1515 Pickering Parkway A 40-storey residential condominium building, containing 571 residential units. Of the proposed units, 1 unit will be through Habitat for Humanity GTA as an affordable housing unit. Site Plan (In progress) Wildav International Developments Limited 1786 Liverpool Road A 48-storey mixed-use building, consisting of 594 residential units, and 190 square metres of commercial space at grade. Of the proposed units, 10 affordable rental units are proposed with monthly rents planned at 80% of the average of the five most recent market rental transactions for units with the same number of bedrooms. The affordable units are proposed to be available for a maximum 10-year period. Site Plan (Dormant) Dunbarton Fairport United Church 1066 Dunbarton Road A 3-storey townhouse development, consisting of 33 stacked townhouse dwelling units and 8 townhouses. All of the proposed units are proposed to be retained by the property owner and be rental tenure, with 30% of the units (approximately 13 units) targeted to be affordable at 80% of the Median Market Rent per the CMHC National Housing Co-Investment Fund criteria. Official Plan Amendment and Zoning By-law Amendment (Dormant) Attachment 3 to Report PLN 18-25 The Affordable Residential Units for the Purposes of the Development Charges Act, 1997 Bulletin Note: The bulletin is effective as of August 1, 2025, and applies until replaced by a new bulletin. The bulletin sets out the market-based (that is, average purchase prices and market rents) and income-based thresholds that are to be used to determine the eligibility of a residential unit for an exemption from development charges and exclusions from the maximum community benefits charge and parkland dedication requirements. Applicable units must be subject to agreements that provide for them to remain affordable residential units for 25 years. Units must also be sold or rented on an arm's length basis. For ownership housing, a unit would be considered affordable when the purchase price is at or below the lesser of: •Income-based purchase price: A purchase price that would result in annual accommodation costs equal to 30% of a household’s gross annual income for a household at the 60th percentile of the income distribution for all households in the local municipality; and •Market-based purchase price: 90% of the average purchase price of a unit of the same unit type in the local municipality. For rental housing, a unit would be considered affordable when the rent is at or below the lesser of: Income-based rent: Rent that is equal to 30% of gross annual household income for a household at the 60th percentile of the income distribution for renter households in the local municipality; and •Market-based rent: Average market rent of a unit of the same unit type in the local municipality. Bulletin for Pickering Affordable Purchase Price: Single Detached, Semi-detached, Townhouse, Condo Apartment $509,800 Affordable Monthly Rent: Bachelor unit $1,273 Affordable Monthly Rent: One Bedroom unit $1,576 Affordable Monthly Rent: Two Bedroom unit $1,672 Affordable Monthly Rent: Three or more Bedroom unit $1,746