Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutOctober 23, 2024Heritage Pickering Advisory Committee Meeting Agenda October 23, 2024 - 7:00 pm Electronic Meeting For information related to accessibility requirements please contact: &RXQFLO Committee Coordinator 905.420.4611 clerks@pickering.ca Members of the public may observe the meeting proceedings by viewing the livestream. Page 1. Review and Approval of Agenda 2. Disclosure of Interest 3. Approval of Minutes 3.1 April 24, 2024 1 4. Delegations 5. New Business 5.1 Presentation from Kim Bradley, Special Advisor, Community Initiatives Re: Seaton Recreation Complex Project 4 5.2 Introduction of Matthew Somerville, Senior Heritage Planner 5.3 Memorandum from Matthew Somerville, Senior Planner, Heritage Re: 1970 Brock Road (Post Manor) 16 5.4 Council Appointment of New Committee Member – November 2024 6. Other Business 7. Next Meeting 8. Adjournment Page 1 of 3 Minutes/Meeting Summary Heritage Pickering Advisory Committee April 24, 2024 Electronic Meeting 7:00 pm Attendees: R. Anderson N. Brewster L. Jeffrey R. Smiles A. Bhadra J. White V. Hicks, Associate & Senior Heritage Planner, MHBC Planning E. Game, Senior Planner, Heritage (Staff Liaison) A. MacGillivray, Council & Committee Coordinator (Recording Secretary) Absent: R. Anderson C. Doody-Hamilton S. Monaghan Item/ Ref # Details & Discussion & Conclusion (summary of discussion) Action Items/Status (include deadline as appropriate) 1. Review and Approval of Agenda Moved by R. Smiles Seconded by L. Jeffrey That the Heritage Pickering Advisory Committee Meeting Agenda of April 24, 2024 be approved. Carried 2. Disclosure of Interest No disclosures of interest were noted. 3. Approval of Minutes Moved by L. Jeffrey Seconded by R. Smiles That the April 10, 2024 Meeting Minutes be approved. Carried 4. Delegations 4.1 Vanessa Hicks, Associate & Senior Heritage Planner, MHBC Planning - 1 - Page 2 of 3 Item/ Ref # Details & Discussion & Conclusion (summary of discussion) Action Items/Status (include deadline as appropriate) Re: Municipal Heritage Register Review and Update - 401 Kingston Road and 1 Evelyn Avenue Vanessa Hicks, Associate & Senior Heritage Planner, MHBC Planning spoke to her support of the staff recommendation regarding 401 Kingston Road as the author of the Heritage Impact Assessment, and indicated that she was available for any questions the Committee had. No questions were posed by the Committee. 5. New Business 5.1 Municipal Heritage Register Review and Update - 401 Kingston Road and 1 Evelyn Avenue Emily Game, Senior Planner, Heritage through the aid of a PowerPoint presentation provided: x an overview of the differences between listed and designated properties under the Ontario Heritage Act; x an overview of the changes to the Ontario Heritage Act from the enactment of Bill 23, More Homes Built Faster Act, 2022; and, x background on the subject properties and the process undertaken to date, including the findings of the Cultural Heritage Impact Assessment. Question and answer period ensued between the Committee and E. Game regarding: x whether consideration of these properties by the Committee takes away time and resources to be considering other matters; x clarification that the properties are currently listed and not registered; x clarification that the properties would be automatically delisted from the Municipal Heritage Register on January 1, 2025 if not designated within the prescribed timelines provided under provincial legislation; x clarification that once the properties are delisted, there would be no protection from demolition or modification; and, - 2 - Page 3 of 3 Item/ Ref # Details & Discussion & Conclusion (summary of discussion) Action Items/Status (include deadline as appropriate) x clarification regarding the properties only meeting 1 of 9 rather than the 2 of 9 criteria required for heritage designation. Moved by N. Brewster Seconded by L. Jeffrey 1. That the properties at 401 Kingston Road and 1 Evelyn Avenue do not meet the threshold established by the Province of Ontario for designation under Part IV, Section 29 of the Ontario Heritage Act, and therefore are not candidates for designation; and, 2. That 401 Kingston Road and 1 Evelyn Avenue be removed from the City of Pickering Municipal Heritage Register. Carried 6. Other Business There was no other business. 7. Next Meeting The next regular meeting of the Heritage Pickering Advisory Committee is scheduled for May 22, 2024. 8. Adjournment Moved by N. Brewster Seconded by R. Smiles That the meeting be adjourned. Carried Meeting Adjourned: 7:30 pm - 3 - Seaton Recreation Complex & Library This state-of-the-art facility will be the first of its kind in Pickering and we want your feedback on its design. For more information on this project contact: Marilou Murray Manager, Community Services Administration & Strategic Initiatives 905.420.4660 ext. 3249 | mmurray@pickering.ca Proposed Amenities: • Aquatics Centre (with 25-metre pool and separate warm water leisure pool) • Triple Gymnasium & Walking Track • Fitness Centre and Studios • 2 Pad Arena • Full Service Library • Multi-purpose Program Rooms • Outdoor Spaces (eg., destination playground, splash pad, sport courts, passive greenspace, and more) Future Site Location: Whitevale Road (Alexander Knox) & Sideline 24 (Burkholder Drive) - 4 - OPEN HOUSE Join Pickering Staff and the design team from Perkins & Will Architects Have Your Say Provide feedback on three design concepts Visit LetsTalkPickering.ca/Seaton or scan this QR code Î for project details, updates, and opportunities to participate. Thursday, October 3 4:30 pm - 7:30 pm CHD Recreation Complex Wednesday, October 9 9:30 am -12:30 pm CHD Recreation Complex Tuesday, October 15 4:30 pm - 7:30 pm Pickering Public Library (Main Branch) - 5 - pickering.ca Community Engagement - October 2024 Letstalkpickering.ca/seaton Seaton Recreation Complex & Library - 6 - pickering.capickering.ca 4 3 2 1 Agenda Project Details Timeline Concept Designs & Amenities Next Steps - 7 - pickering.ca We're bringing a brand-new Recreation Complex & Library to Pickering! • Indoor Amenities: Twin-pad Arena, Aquatic facility (two tanks); Full-service Library, Triple Gymnasium, Indoor Running/Walking Track, Fitness Centre & Exercise Studios • Outdoor Amenities: Skateboard Park, Dedicated Basketball Courts, Pickleball Courts, Tennis Courts, Splash Pad, Destination Play Structure, Community Garden, Civic Square, Optional: Refrigerated Skating Trail, Stage/Event Area • This will be Pickering’s first multipurpose recreation complex built since the Pickering Recreation Complex (now the Chestnut Hill Developments Recreation Complex) opened in 1983. • Funding for the project has been committed. Facility to open in 2029. Project Details - 8 - pickering.ca Site Map – Location: Site is located between Brock Road (east), Whites Road (west), Taunton Rd (south), Hwy 407 (north). Site is 6.4 hectares in total. Project Details Br o c k R o a d Hwy 407 Taunton Road - 9 - pickering.ca Timeline - 10 - pickering.ca • Early phase of the design process. • Enables exploration of different possibilities. • Facilitates alignment of design solutions with user needs and expectations. • Provides a foundation for further iterations prior to final detailed design Schematic/Concept Design vs. Detailed Design - 11 - pickering.ca Concept Designs - 12 - pickering.ca Amenities - 13 - pickering.ca Have Your Say! • Review the Designs. • Complete the Survey - tell us what you like best about each design, and/or what you would change. • Cast a vote on your preferred design and tell us why you choose that design! • Follow along for project updates: LetsTalkPickering.ca/Seaton Next Steps - 14 - pickering.ca Marilou Murray Manager, Community Services Administration & Strategic Initiatives Community Services Department 905.420.4660 ext. 3249 mmurray@pickering.ca - 15 - Memo To: Heritage Pickering Advisory Committee October 18, 2024 From: Matthew Somerville Senior Planner, Heritage Copy: Division Head, Development Review & Urban Design Subject: 1970 Brock Road (Post Manor) File: A-3300-069 The purpose of this memo is to provide an update to the Heritage Pickering Advisory Committee on a Heritage Permit Application for 1970 Brock Road, also known as Post Manor, which is designated under Part IV of the Ontario Heritage Act. Order to Comply On September 5, 2024, an Order to Comply was issued to Brock and Kingston Holdings Inc., the owner of the property, requiring them to obtain a building permit to legalize the division of the commercial space in the Post Manor building into two units. Building permit records from 1997 show that the space was originally intended for single occupancy. On October 10, 2024, a Heritage Permit Application was received. A Heritage Permit is required when alterations affect a designated heritage attribute. In this case, the by-law designates two marble fireplace surrounds as interior heritage attributes. These features will not be affected by the proposed changes. The proposed alterations involve installing washrooms to accommodate the separation of the space into two units. Please refer to the drawings on page 2 of the ERA Architects Heritage Permit Application Memo: 1970 Brock Road, Pickering (refer to Attachment 1) for a visual description of the 1997 permit drawings and the 2024 Building Permit Drawings from CMV Architects. The Order to Comply will bring the interior alterations into compliance with the Ontario Building Code requirements. Heritage staff have determined that the proposed alterations do not require a Heritage Permit as prescribed under the Ontario Heritage Act. However, the Pickering Heritage Advisory Committee is being kept informed of all ongoing work related to this property. Future Mixed-Use Development In March 2023, Council approved applications for an Official Plan Amendment and a Zoning ByǦlaw Amendment to allow the redevelopment of the property into a high-density, mixed-use development. The proposal includes two towers, one 30 storeys and one 12 storeys, containing - 16 - October 18, 2024 Page 2 of 2 1970 Brock Road (Post Manor) approximately 623 apartment units and 1,825 square metres of commercial space, including 355 square metres of commercial space within the Post Manor building. It also includes 52 fourǦstory stacked townhouses. The proposal retains the Post Manor building at the corner of Kingston Road and Brock Road, but will be moved approximately 18 metres, closer to Brock Road. As of now, an application for Site Plan Approval has not been submitted. The Pickering Heritage Advisory Committee will have further opportunities to review and comment on the conservation plan for the Post Manor building during the Site Plan review process, as well as consider an updated designating by-law for the property. MS:nr /CityDevDept/A3300/A-3300-069 1970 Kingston Road Post Manor/Order to Comply (2024)/Heritage Memo - Oct_17_24.docx Attachment 1. Heritage Permit Application - ERA Architects Heritage Permit Application Memo: 1970 Brock Road, Pickering - 17 - PAGE 1 OF 3 ERA Architects Inc. #600-625 Church St Toronto ON, M4Y 2G1 October 10, 2024 Heritage Permit Application Memo: 1970 Brock Road, Pickering This Heritage Permit Application is being made to accompany a concurrent Building Permit Application to )"$)&7"+"5&01&+$Ǿ14,Ȓ2+&1 ,**"/ &) ,+!&1&,+,+1%"$/,2+!Ɲ,,/,#1%"2&)!&+$1ǖǞǜǕ/, (,! țȈ1%"-/,-"/16ȋȜǽ%"-/,-"/16&0!"0&$+1"!2+!"//1 ,#1%"Ontario Heritage ActǾ66Ȓ)4,ǽǗǚǜǕȒ ǖǞǝǜǽ Reasons for Designation %"#,)),4&+$"0,+0#,/"0&$+1&,+/"&+ )2!"!&+6)4,ǽǗǚǜǕȒǖǞǝǜǿ The stone farmhouse commonly known as Post Manor which is located at Brock Road and Kingston Road, a major intersection in the Town of Pickering was built in 1841. At that time the house was in a rural setting surrounded by farmland and dusty concession roads. Jordan Post, from Toronto, moved to Pickering with his wife Matilda in 1838 and proceeded to construct 1%"%,*"ǽ&1%01,+"#,2+!1&,++! 21Ɯ")!01,+""51"/&,/Ǿ1%"%,20"&0016)&01+!012/!6ǽ%"/"/" 0%("+!*"1)/,,#0Ǿ+"5 "-1&,+)3"/+!%1/&**"!4&1%$&+$"//"!+!!"1&)"! %&*+"60#,/1%" 14,&+1"/&,/*/)"Ɯ/"-) "0ǽ%"*&+!,,/%&+101 /""("3&3)16)"-,-2)/11%"1&*"ǽ+)61%" "011&*"/4020"!#/,*1%"#*&)6*&))#,/&+1"/&,/1/&*+!Ɲ,,/0ǽ+&.2"%/!4/"Ǿ*,/1// ("10Ǿ shutters and windows compliment this comfortable century building. There is an unusual arched entrance to the basement. Description of Proposed Work , 2//"+14,/(&0-/,-,0"!ǽ +/" "+16"/0Ǿ %+$"&+20"402+!"/1("+4%"/"&+1%"0&+$)" ,**"/ &)2+&1,+1%"2&)!&+$ȉ0$/,2+!Ɲ,,/40 ,+3"/1"!&+1,14, ,**"/ &)2+&10ǽ %"&16,#& ("/&+$ȉ0*,01/" "+12&)!&+$-"/*&1/" ,/!0ț#/,*ǖǞǞǜȜ)"$)&7"0&+$)"$/,2+!ȒƝ,,/ ,**"/ &)2+&1Ǿ11%"1&*"/")"011",ƛ& "ǽ%" 2//"+1 ,+!&1&,+0-)&101%"$/,2+!Ɲ,,/"14""+ ,**"/ &)2+&1&+1%"#/,+1Ǿ*&+-,/1&,+,#1%"2&)!&+$ț2/%*+,/"))+"00 ")1%"/3& "0Ȝ+! 1%",/&$&+)/"/"51"+0&,+,#1%"2&)!&+$ț,-%&/, %&/,-/ 1,/Ȝǽ +"-1"*"/ǚǾǗǕǗǙǾ1%"-/,-"/16,4+"//" "&3"!+/!"/1,,*-)6#/,*1%"&16,#& ("/&+$ȉ0 2&)!&+$-"/*&1!"-/1*"+1Ǿ4%& % (+,4)"!$"!1%11%"2&)!&+$40!&3&!"!&+1,*,/"1%+,+"02&1" 4&1%,211%""+"Ɯ1,#2&)!&+$-"/*&1ǽ%"/!"/1,,*-)6/".2&/"!1%"-/,-"/16,4+"/1,,1&+ 2&)!&+$-"/*&11,/"1/, 1&3")6)"$)&7"1%" %+$"Ǿ,//"3"/11%"0&1"1,&10,/&$&+)--/,3"! ,+!&1&,+ǽ ""1%"#,)),4&+$-$"#,/ ,*-/&0,+"14""+1%"0&+$)"Ȓ2+&1$/,2+!Ɲ,,/ ,+!&1&,+--/,3"!&+ǖǞǞǜǾ +!1%" 2//"+114,Ȓ2+&1 ,+!&1&,+1%1&0-/,-,0"!1,")"$)&7"!3&1%&0--)& 1&,++! ,+ 2//"+1 Building Permit Application. $WWDFKPHQW - 18 - PAGE 2 OF 3 ERA Architects Inc. #600-625 Church St Toronto ON, M4Y 2G1 UP TO GRADE UP 2580 10355 140 5 9 1022711796 14 0 9 7 12 7 3 204 5 43 4 7 616 0 27 2 BASEMENT UNEXCAVATED STORAGE STORAGE OPEN D W HW S/A S/A S/A S/A R/A R/A R/A T T F#1 F#2 S/P FURNACEVENTS TO CONDENSING UNITS FLOOR MTD.TRANSFORMERS WALL MTD.EL. PANELStypical NOTE:-FURNACE #1 (F#1) SERVES DURHAMMANOR WELLNESS HEALTHSERVICES TENANT ONLY-FURNACE #2 (F#2) SERVES TOPCHIRO CHIROPOPRACTOR TENANT ONLYSEPARATE THERMOSTATS AS NOTED ONGROUND FLOOR PLAN UTILITYROOM F#2 SUPPLYAIR UP SANITARYDRAIN DN DN DN UP UP DN DN 2580 10355 14 0 5 9 18471023311796 14 0 9 7 12 7 3 204 5 43 4 7 61 6 0 27 2 DN F.P. F.P . WR VEST. 'DURHAM MANOR WELLNESS HEALTH SERVICES' TENANT'TOPCHIRO' CHIROPRACTOR TENANT ENTRY OFFICE TREATMENT OFFICE OFFICE OFFICE VEST. TREATMENT RECEPTION ENCLOSED COURTYARD RAMP PORCH BASEMENT STAIR ACCESSIBLE ENTRANCE BROKEN LINE DENOTES LOCATION OF SEPARATION BETWEEN THE TWO GROUND FLOOR TENANTS. PER OBC 3.3.1.1.(1)., THE SEPARATION IS PERMITTED TO BE A 0hr CONDITION (SMOKE BARRIER). THE VESTIBULE DOORS SHOWN ARE TO BE EQUIPPED ACCORDINGLY WITH WEATHER-STRIPPING AND FLOOR SWEEPS TO ENSURE SMOKE TIGHTNESS EXISTING SOLID MASONRY WALL 2-PIECE WASHROOM FOR THE EXCLUSIVE USE OF THIS TENANT NOTES: 1. MORE THAN 1 EGRESS DOORWAY AVAILABLE EACH SUITE 2. MAXIMUM TRAVEL DISTANCE TO EGRESS DOORWAY <25m FORCED AIR SUPPLY DUCTS IN CEILING S/A THERMOSTAT THERMOSTAT TREATMENT DN DN 10355 140 5 9 10233 14 0 9 7 LOBBY 6 / 1 2 6 / 1 2 LOBBYWR OFFICE OFFICE OFFICEOFFICEOFFICE STOR. 'DURHAM MANOR WELLNESS HEALTH SERVICES' TENANT ROOFOVERPORCHBELOWROOFOVERGROUNDFLOORBELOW (2 Fixtures) BR O C K R O A D KINGST O N R O A D #1970 EXISTING2-STOREYHERITAGEBUILDING #1980 EXISTING1-STOREY BLDG. EXISTING1-STOREY BLDG. (SWISS CHALET) #1670 EXISTING1-STOREY BLDG. SIDEWALK ENCLOSEDCOURTYARD SID E W A L K SID E W A L K LANDSCAPING LAN D S C A P I N G LA N D S C A P I N G EXISTINGSURFACEPARKING REARENTRANCE FRONTENTRANCE LANDSCAPING ACCESSIBLEENTRANCEGATE FENCING PO R C H PAD MOUNTEDCONDENSING UNITS INCOMING NATURALGAS & METER EXISTINGSURFACEPARKING EXISTINGSURFACEPARKING EXISTINGSURFACEPARKING EXISTINGSURFACEPARKING PR O P E R T Y L I N E PROPE R T Y L I N E 1st Floor 0 2nd Floor 3320 t/o Roof 7238 Basement -2200 1st Floor 0 2nd Floor 3320 t/o Roof 7238 Basement -2200 1st Floor 0 2nd Floor 3320 t/o Roof 7238 Basement -2200 1st Floor 0 2nd Floor 3320 t/o Roof 7238 Basement -2200 Seal: ISO A0 Checked By: Oct 02, 2024 - 12:02pm Drawing No.: Date Plotted: Drawn By: Drawing Title: Project: Revision No.: Scale: Date Checked:Project No. DateNo. REVISIONS AND DISTRIBUTION LOG Note &DPGHQ6WUHHW 7RURQWR2QWDULR 099 ZZZFPYDUFKFRP 7) A100 2 AS NOTED EXISTING HERITAGE BUILDING TENANT LAYOUT 1970 BROCK ROAD PICKERING ONTARIO OBC MATRIX, SITE PLAN FLOOR PLANS & ELEVATIONS RC DC SEPT. 2024 20A109 1 19 SEP 2024 ISSUED FOR REVIEW AND COMMENT 2 02 OCT 2024 SUBMITTED FOR BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION KEY PLAN (NTS) SITE Above: ǖǞǞǜ2&)!&+$ "/*&1/4&+$0#,/0&+$)" retail unit on the building’s $/,2+!Ɲ,,/ț&16,# & ("/&+$Ȝǽ "ƞǿ2024 Building "/*&1/4&+$0#,/14, commercial units on the 2&)!&+$ȉ0$/,2+!Ɲ,,/Ȁ separation between the units denoted by a dotted ) ()&+"ț/ %&1" 10Ȝǽ - 19 - PAGE 3 OF 3 ERA Architects Inc. #600-625 Church St Toronto ON, M4Y 2G1 11%&001$"Ǿ/ %&1" 10%0-/"-/"!2&)!&+$"/*&1/4&+$1%1 2/1")6/"Ɲ" 101%" 2//"+1 ,+!&1&,+Ǿ4%& %0-)&101%"2&)!&+$&+1,14, ,**"/ &)2+&10ț0""-/"3&,20-$"Ǿ+!#2))0"111 %"! with this application). Heritage Impact Assessment %"/"&0+, %+$"1,1%"2&)!&+$ȉ0&+1"/&,/)6,21/"02)1&+$#/,*1%" ,+3"/0&,+1,14,2+&101%1%0 +6&*- 1,+1%"-/,-"/16ȉ0 2)12/)%"/&1$"3)2"Ǿ0/1& 2)1"!&+&10"0,+0#,/"0&$+1&,+ǽ%" !"0&$+1&,+6Ȓ)40-" &Ɯ"01%"#,)),4&+$&+1"/&,/#"12/"0ǿ +)61%""011&*"/4020"!#/,*1%"#*&)6*&))#,/&+1"/&,/1/&*+!Ɲ,,/0ǽ+&.2"%/!4/"Ǿ*,/1/ brackets, shutters and windows compliment this comfortable century building. ,+",#1%"0"&+1"/&,/#"12/"00201&++6&*- 1#/,*1%" ,+3"/0&,+1,14,2+&10ǽ%"2&)!&+$ 2//"+1)6 ,+1&+2"01,"20"!&+4601%1/"0"+0&1&3"1,&10&+1 1%&01,/& &+1"/&,/ %/ 1"/ǽ Conclusion ȉ000"00*"+1Ɯ+!01%11%"/"&0+,%"/&1$"&*- 1/"02)1&+$#/,*1%&0 %+$"&+ ,**"/ &)2+&10 4&1%&+1%"$/,2+!Ɲ,,/,#1%"2&)!&+$1ǖǞǜǕ/, (,!ǽ%&0 "/&1$""/*&1--)& 1&,+&0*!"1, )"$)&7" 2//"+1 ,+!&1&,+,+1%"-/,-"/161%1&0 ,*-1&)"4&1%&10%"/&1$"3)2"Ǿ0!"0 /&"!&+&10 designation by-law. - 20 -