HomeMy WebLinkAboutCL 6/99. i
Y g �. .
O�a OF p�
�
REPORT TO COUNCIL
FROM: Bruce Taylor, AMCT, CMM DATE: January 20, 1999
'fo�m Clerk
REPORT NUMBER: CL 6-99
SUBIECT: Independent Consullant to Monitor Ontario Hydro Economic Impact Study
RECOMMENDATION:
That the proposal submitted by Jack Gartley Consulting dated ]enuary 18, 1999 to act as ihc
Independent Consultant for the Town to monitor lhe Economic Impact Study of the Pickering
and Darlington Nuclear Generating Stations by Ontario Hydra be accepted subject to
confirmalion that Ontario Hydra will pay the costs of the Independent Consultant as set out in the
proposai.
ORIGIN:
Commitment made by Carl Andognini in letter dated October 22, 1998
AUTHORITY:
Municipal Act
FlNANC[AL IMPL[CATIONS:
Cost of Independent Consultrnt lo be maximum of 520,000 to be o�'set by funding from Onlario
Hydro.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY:
To accept the ofTer made by Ced Andognini, Executive Vice President and Chief Nuclear OfTcer,
Ontario Hydro, dated October 22, 1998 to pay for an Indepr.�dent Consuhant to monitor ihe
progress of the Economic Impact Study of the Pickering and Darlington Nuclear Generating
Stations by Ontario Hydro.
BACKGROUND:
Please find attached to this Report a letter from Carl Andognini, Executive Vica President and
Chief Nuclear Ofl9cer, Ontario Hydro, dated October 22, 1998, confirming that Ontario Hydro
will ba undertaking an Economic Impact Study of the Pickering and Darlington Nuclear
Generating Stations and oftering to pay a reasonable amount of money for ihe Town to rctain an
Independrnt Consultant to monitor the progress of t�ie Study.
.,../2
;
..z..
99
Also attached to this Report is a proposal submitted by Jack Gartley Consulting to act as that
Independent Consultant at a maximum cost of S20,000. I would recommend that Counci) accept
this proposal subject to conRrmation from Carl Mdognini that Ontario Hydro will pay the costs
of the Independent Consultent. I understand that Ontaria Hydro hopes to commence this Swdy
some time in February, iherefore, there is some urgency in having our Independent Consultant in
place.
A7"fACI-IMENTS:
I. Letter from Carl Mdognini dated October 22, 1998
2. Proposel from ]ack Gnriley Consulling dated lanuary I8, 1999
Prepared By:
rucc Taylor, AMCT, CMM
Town Clerk
Recommended for the consideration of
Pickering To�m Council
� �xo
T omas l. ' n,
ChiefAdministrative OfTcer
. , ' ama�ar+vd�
, !�`r.. . .. �►RA��M�TOw�onr�=.�-'�; �"a „
��a ��.
�
a c.d �neet�r�r, E.wnn. vk. vrwa�r
md qiid N�rN�f 011le�
October2Z, 1998 ��/. : ^ ';�;�
i ,/ }�, ',��
Mayor Wayne Anhun ' � � '�
Pickering Civic Complex l : � � °`� ' /
1 'llu Esplanade � r'' � t�;"
Pickering, Oatario ��1
LlV 6K7 _
Dc�ar Mayor Arthuc-,
r.iwnanu I���1 sn•2oC�
Fu µtl� 6Y24l71
C�OUIU (�f 0) SIO�l7
I went w take this oppoRunity W thanlc you for youc commenu la�t night at the Pickering
Publlc Meeting. We will continue ta wark togethu witlt the Town of Pickering and �eep
an open dialogue.with the communiry especially as we loo� to the ttstaR of Pickering A
Unit�.
,, We were pleased to have the opportuniry to provide the community with assurana of the .
safe opemtion of aur pient end example� of improvemenu to date. [ am confident that
you witl see continued improvement in che funue as we move back to a"worid cles�
pedocmer".
A� I announced lest aight, Ontario Hydro will undertake aa Economic Review of the
Impac� of the Nuclear Facilides in the rcgion of Dur6em aad the host commuaide� of
Pickering and Clarington. Ontario Hydro offrn to the Town of Pickering, a�asonable
amount of money to pay for an wdependent coroultant who can monitor the progress of
the Economic Unpact Study. OHN ha� designated Pat 0'Brien a� our contact for the
study. He can be rcached at 905•839-1 I51— Ext 5966. I looN fonvard to �eceiving yaur
proposal for an independeot roviow including the cosn.
Again, thank you to you and your council memben for taking �he time to attend aur
Public Meeting lazt night
" Cazl do '
Execudve Vice Prdident 8t
Chief Nucleaz Offica
ce. P.0'Bden . •
R. Strickert
. ii
,
, 1
{ V, .
. .... .. . . d� .. . .� �.r�. �
� � .. . . li � . . . � ..
- . ... . � ii . . . . . ..
. . . rf .. , _ . . � . . � .
� � . . �`� . .. . .. . . . .
' 1
,
racn : Jack cAaner caa�.�ri�� FKt ia. : roa ew> s?�: Jan. �9 l?33 t1:0�11 a�
JACK GARTLEY CONSUL T/NG � �Z
MUNICIPAL FINANCE
18 Glen Dhu Orive Tol. Na (905)668•8J20
IM�ilby, ON Fax No. (905)668•0002
L1R 1H8 E•mai�: jlbp�sprinl.w
January 18, 19:i9
Mr. Bruce Taylor, AMCT, CMM
Town Clerk
The Corporalion of lhe Town of Pickenng
One the Esplanade
Pickering, ON
L1 V 6K7
Dear eruce
Ro: Proposal to Act as an Indepundent Consultant for the Town to
Monitor the applicable Ontario Hydro Economic Impact Study
I enjoyed working as a consultant lo Gil Paterson and his staff in lhe Towii's
Finance Dep�rtment, periodically, dunng 1998 I Irust my employment proved to
be beneflcial to Ihem.
The pos�ibility of working for Ihe Town again as an independenl con9ullant to
monitor the applicable Onlano Hydro Economic Impect Study would be equally
challenging lo me.
As requested, please consider Ihis letter and atlachmenls as rny proposal lor
ihis undaiiakinfl.
I ant(cipate thal I would need to spend approximately 30 man days on Ihis
praject. Thiswouldinclude:
. preparing for and attendmg meelings with Ihe main consultant, hosted by
Onlario Hydro as well as maetings wilh Ihe Town Coun:il
• undertaking research and holding d(scusefons with other persons stlend�ng
meetinge ot consultant which are necessary lo allow me to complele my work
fo everyGne's satisfaction
ji
,,
�
,,
'`
�
� FFQ1 : JACK GARTLEY CQSIITI�IG FrOtlq. ;?0; 6r,6 °,9?2 � Jdn. �0 1�l�3 11:02H1 P3
�17L
Mr. Bruce Taylor, AMCT, CMM
Page 2
January 18, 1999
My estimate of lhe cost to lhe To�vn of employmg me in lhis endeavour would be
in lhe range oi $16,o001u $20,000.
Details on the dralt termc ot roference for Ihe independent consultant, the main
consultant lo be hired by Ontario Hydro, my time and costs on Ihe project, and
my background in r6ialion to Ihe pro�ect are included for your further
consideratlon as altachmenls 1 l0 5 inclusive, respectively.
Please cantact me if you have any queslions or if you have any commenls you
would Iike to make. Your consideration lo this malter would be apprecialed.
Yours sincerely
Jack Ga y
Jlg,lb
Altachments
1,
�
, :
FROM :; JACK CFRTLEY tOftSI.1.TItIG FrY< fq. : 4p5 6b5 5?22 Jan. l8 t999 pg;;�p1 PJ
�
1. �3
Atlachmenl 1
DRAFT TERMS OF REFERENCE
tor
THE RETENT�ON BY THE TOWN OF PICKERING
OF AN INDEPENDENT CONSULTANT
to Monitor tha Progress ot a Conaultant Hired by Ontario Hydro
to Untlertake an Economic Review of the Impact of Qhe Nuclear FacillUes
in the Region ot Uufiam, and More Parttcularly, •
the Host Communities of Ptckerinp and Clarington
Ttmeframe oi Studv
Il is understood that the ECOnomic Review Is anticipeted lo slart around
February 1. 1999 and that il 3hould take approximately three months lo
cample�v, e.g., April 30, 1999.
Meetinas with the Main Consultant
Eight all-day meetings are expecled to take placo with the consultant and other
Interested parlies.
Meetinas bv Independent Consultant wifh Town Council
it is predicled that there will be three meetings with Ihe Town Council lasting
approximelely one hour each.
Discussions with Otherinterested Parties
It Is understood that it is Ihe Town Council's �ntenl to allow the independent
consulfant to carry out his duties in Ihe most beneficfal manner ensunng that Ihe
Tuwn's (nlereets are protecled.
Representatfves of Clarington and the Region may attend meetings with the
consultant hosted by Ontario Hydro and items ot mutual interest and concerns
related to the progress of Ihe Sfudy will be discussed wilh these representotives,
if appropriate.
I �
�
'
�on :. Jaac cswner ca�t,uu� Fasc �a. : Qo; r'xe s?.a ta�. ie i5� oe::�.ua �
, ,
�� z�4 ,
D�ait Tertna ot Reierence — Paqe 2
It Is sntic(pated Ihat meetlngs with Onterio Hydro representatives witl be required
to review and clarify results of lracking efforts by the two nuclear facflfties
undertaken In the past. This tracking wvuld relale to the cosls and expenditures
that have been mainlained wfiich would assist in understanding tha basic
economic benefits of heving these facilities located in lhe host communities.
Deliverables
At the first maeting lvith Council, the (ndependern consullant would provide a
pretiminary presentalion on his/her expeclatians of the results of the Study.
Af lhe second meeling that would be hetd approximate�y half way lhrough the
Study, Ihe independent consultant would bring Council up lo dala on Ihe sfatus
of the Sludy,
At the final meeting, the indopendent consullant would be reqwred to present
the findings of the Sludy and lo pive hismer views on the accuracy and lhe
soundness of these tindings.
{
�. .
1:
` 1
, ,
•"' <
,
i�.i`:4 . . . ;. . 4 .., . . , ? . ' . . . . . , . � �
FI?OM :.JACK GARTLEY COrEALTING . FfOfID. : 905 666 59� lan. 18 1939 O8:'EiM P6 �
� �t �l5
' Attachmenl2
6mnomle Jmp�n Aun�m�nt of Meyvin� ��d D�rlin�bn C��.ndn� Suqon,
OrJt Tersw of A�f�nna
YLLm�et�
To undauica o itudy io Id�ntlly �h� «oeemk Imp�eu of Onnrio Hydro'i Piekenn� uid
Darlln�tan fxEUUu on hait cocununmu �na We Re{ton of Du�nun.
H�aklmY44=
Allhay! th� tt�tlam Awe trtdltlon�llr tr�ckd eosu irtd eipendl�ura (n �n eflo� ro
andet�hnd tM bw aonomie benefit of � fuil(da, � mare deullad �nd comphh�ndv�
�tudy U tequind to {denrily �hdr tLli aonomk impKr. pvar dr lat two �wn, N�r A�
ban eonurn expr.ued by aakeholder aoupr n�d t!w Town of PlCimcin� �bovt fM
imprcts d tM Plok�rin{ stuion oa N� e0comu�dry. In tha NowtnbK 1997 nwnielptl
ebctlon. ralJea4 eadorµA � pl�blieite wllin� Pot m rnvirpnmmt�! wufmrnt; uid �he
AICD, t1 pan o! tu Ileenw eoedluon�, mquaud w���roM,,�n�i ye���
tnfOrto�tlaa.
An Ind.p.ndrm ecoeomk u,e.�mm� ord,e �unoar Ma,la prow �u �nedw wpami
elem«� la d.�aminina �he full imp�ec of d�� �ayon, 1AIs q pu�kululy Impaunt wleA
. dw pounA� n�u¢c ot PIelc�dn� ti Oeurio Hydro wk: ord �D�tw uc�4nw+dln� ot
t4u� lmpuu to iulify eoneuni � pul ol aur aypio� xNuholdm rclaebaa Pm�m,
In rddluen, u a retult of tceen� prorindil uoeedmmu m 7}r Muq[t1p11 Act d(ktln�
muNdpal pvemmeae �wears �nd euwon, ihe Town ol Pfclrsdn� will no lan�er roialn
boR aommunlrY D�Y�u in Ibu of tuM (P141 Rom Otf wio Hydro uid taden!
d�pwnenu ind ptovlxltl minitqu. A�lMr, mw �m�,,., �u� a mra«a �o wa
ro�iond qov�mm�nc To m�ke up ma �hortfill, tl�e ToMn of Pickenn� pwad � rtwdon u
In Octobw 17' nuedn� co undaukr � p,.umi�u�, n�n �w would uc ouc �riow ro"
eabuet � ewdy cf cJr rapble ud inuapbt� bnaeflu to the Town ot PieluAat af eha
PiekMn� Nuelw rJ�n�ndn� Sutton. 1ha rcpert b due in tlx wwka' prt+e ond i�
Intead�d to be the bui� lor unie� Uantr (ow �o qloa Piakenn� ;VUCIeu to con4a:�
operufau In tAe communny. Under Vu le��on, fuch :Icenu� rtuy oeJy be pafsib!c if
�Aas (t � nejulre ewnomk tenetlt to uu Town,
��
The n�ed for �Ea etudy � eWo-fela: �;1 � ne�a (ot � rnponu b queationi �tked by :he
Town af 1'ktatn� u w�«eno;nte imp�u ol Ne Piekenn� fuiliry on �Ae Tor�, d�a
a
� ,_�4<i � .. . . . . . . .. . .
. . . . . .'. ... . . .
.. � � . . � . � . � . t ;. .. � . .
,e�. . .. � � . � . .. ,. � � . � � .
yfi
..f .. . � � ., '
.t . .i � :..... .. .. . . . . - . .. . ' _. _ — .—
FR011 :, JACK GfiRTLE'f COtISU.TI��i . FAX �q. :?OS tiEei 59?3 lan. l8 1999 08:;;fN P7
t f1 �. f.) tM nad f0� s 6w�d�r ft�dy la NJy un0�nund �M �eor.omie co�inbuuai wu aur
f�e�Iiuu and �mpior�a muee ca m. Ix�! aommunitiu u+e we Res�oa of Dure�m.
W11La11l+
A rpoR dut wlll bt prorid�d �o tM Tow� af Pie�Kin' ue tAe Rc�wn of Uuham on Ne
�eonomle imp�e� o! uu uurd lu��c mewrty In uu tepon; i�, lhe Pftltetint �nd
Dallnnon NueMu W neeaun� 9taUonz '�Tb npon WU wrve u a eml� !a wakins
WIiS �A� To�rn �nd tNa 0.epon in helpin� th�m mat �a�u ot thctr need� and help On�nrto
Hydro. hwt eommunida i�d cAe Re�ion, md �av�mmen� a{�nc;u undersund �hs
eontr;budoe Nu OHN't balitta ruke w tllo lad oeC re�ion�l aanomlu.
��
Tha ttudy will idandfy �A; �he aonomie impu4 of Ne on+0luj openJOne oJ Piekertng
Nuabat 6S, on the Tovn of PiekMn{ �nd tde Re on of Du�hun i IuNn� tlw laetl
impaa on O�e�wy WEfcby� srA Aju, ied m � c For tni� part of �M
uWytll, �I» tdQy will inClad� N� uu�m�pt o(tD� rutut of Piekarie� A aad wy
�eoeomia No�lk� of rhe raw .e�vilir. k Mlll atso e.+�wae �e lon�•rsrm imyaeu an
N� loal Nd npon� eeonoraia wi�ha+i a Pickuie� � ruuut, pnJJy. u wlll ideodfr
cde eeonomk imp�ey ,u«ivad+l�h au aKOma�!uionins of tM Woka{n� tKUlty.
G 41CJ�on. �M Rudy will ida+tlty (B) ou eeatamlc Impau ol:he oaQoln� opuadmu of
Dvilapufn Nuelur G.S. on rhe Re�:en o! Durham incivain� �a Ixsl Imp�cu on �h�
Tovm� ef A)u, WEltby�nd ;afn on,
O
Hy etuoinin� ih� mmbined twultt of (Ai 4t0 (B). t!a sady will identify Ne aonomie
impxn ot �h� Wekedny �nd Dulm�can luillGa on ho�t eommumtlu �nd �he Retion uf
Darhtm.
SOOal�
The uudy will identi(y, 5u� wl;l no: De limlted �o, iAe (o!low:n� i�epacu:
�D�oYromt
(A)•the dGm, iodtreet ud mduc.d enpioynwnt �ywunE from �he on`oir.� openiion nf
tM PlekMns A we 8�nuoni uiamin� � �cY�dnS A suian. ipe �twn•ier�
. rmployamM wxlu�e wia� � roron et Piekmn� n, th� lou o! lan���ertn employrt;en�
uwciYea wl� iAt non.ru�,u� of Pickenn� A, u;d the iuu of empioy,;um v:ociuea
WItA tA� dccomrr�utaur,t of Pu�adn� NuctaaG.S.
i. _ .
'
fFOM :�IACK GARTLEI' CCtISL1LTIIG F�Uf Iq. ; 905 r'66 ;92<^ Jan, 18 1339 Og:;;k7 FA
(8)•th� ditsec. lndinel �nd Induccd employmmt tYwlUnf from Uw an�o�o( cpotwon of ��"�
Dalla�toa Nw•�e�r O,J.
�0W ��i �4d8p�edtns
fA)•th� moaey �peut Ey wc Pick�rinp A�nd 8 mdca� babladl� ud rcjlondir tw
thelr on�oc�� o�entlon Y�umin� � P(ekuin� A rowvt th� monay +prut by Onttlo
�Y� �� taally u�d ropondly on ihe niurt c( Nckedn� A, �6e lou tn lael �od
nd�� oPuWar parclwln� if ideco ii ao Plckeln� A na.it, u�d the unounc ol
dl�pou6la Pdawy a�d wcanduy Iacmw �twe(ued v1N Pkkarin� employon �nd rhe'u
f+�� (� �►dW wd w:�qwl Plckario� A) �od sh� �mouat of local ud rcpood
�Pa►Qlej woaiwd wIW Ontuio Hydro amployw aad dKlr hmllla Uvina In tE� Town
o(Plokerinl� tod t!M iw otd(�po�t6ta incoar �od loc4 wd ro�icm! ipeadipa
waime �cn m. �,�,,,�;L�,,,i�i,r a�s a.s.
�}rlf� mowy �peat by rhe Derlln�on ewlon bah laelly iad rcponeUy falq oapin�
°Pr+u� +nd �he �a�ount of diipw�blr w�ona auoci�md wi�h Dulin�mn aeployw
�ad theh fmdllu md th� ruuluot unoust olloul �nQ npond fpecsdio�,
Pepubtlou aed Antdeaa
(A3�he tohl oumbar o!P[ckerin7 eroDlcYees �na raulnnt popul�don rufdln{ in ihe
�1�+ ��+h�m and cp�clflc�ly sqldio� In pickmin�, pfp�w�, W�iltyy� �od A)u, �nd
ta t1u C(ry of Stuborou�h.
•the outaber of Oaterio Hydro nmploya�,.�clndlaP �i�oao fiom Pickain� huetou U.9..
u�d rolaed poputasion �td;no m �Ae rown atPlckain�
•the Iou of �mploY� u�d populWon uracl�ad �.ith the non•cnun of Plckerfng A
•t4e Ioer of emplaYeq uW populWon auoeiued wlt6 the deca4aJulonin� of Pickttint
C' 9,
(8)•the tou! oumperpf pali�� emP�QYou �nd �er�lunt populuion :aiding !n the
Re�loa oPDurhua �od �p�ciRW�y r�Id1oQ In Clulnamn. ,�u, and avh�thy.
Mualdpall7aaac�
(A}IL� +mouM ol PIL utd ennu wotittsd �rith th� Pickuin� A+nd 9 eudoat pud ro
tM 7ocvo ot Pldmdn� y hon commwiry �nd m �he Re�lan o! Durqun by p�terio
HY�. Gld�r�l joreenamnt 6tptttrmnu, ud Onwlo provituid ministtia� �nd eay
c��° ��u Q6a°'t'+i0C1a°'d w��� +aon•rMUtt of Plokain� A �nd the
d�nKadoalo� of YklcaleR p.9.
-tE� uaauns of tWt wxiwd wiW Wcketln� emploreea aud Weir fuailla pdd to Rhe
%wa et Ple�, md Oeh.w� R�hi�br. uul �u wd th� CI o(Se .
tmauet of tuu ayoetu� Mi�h �l rnhc Onur{o H ry �0��6 m4 t6e
�° �PbY� n�ldln` in No Town
I .
j
FRU1 � JiiCl� GARTLEY fpPISILTIfIG FitK �q, :?OS i�» 59?2 Jan. l9 1999 03: y,�1 p9
�. nH � Pklurin� uid pdd to the Town. �nd c6uuu la Nsre �mounta u�ociued w;� t aon•
' rairt af Pktqiq� A �nd the decoromlulonins u( Pickeciot 0.9.
'� �arbu of EiriauKe in Na Tawo ot Plctrna� �ad in Ocluw� vVhltby, aad Aj�
Wooial�d rrld� dl Ontuio Hydro �mployw� �qd their faniUa talC(n� in tbo
�ommudda �ad tM nluW u:a pdd w t�:sunteipditia.nd cb�c�ro ro dsu number
bMW aa1 me:�•nitut of Plcke�{s� A md �h� ditommLUonin� olPidur{n� O.S.
(8)�+roount cf PII� �cd gnnu walr�d Mim Dvlln�ta� Nutiea OS. pdd m
�i� a t6o bon eommunlry aad Uti Re{ian of DuAum by On4tio HyQco� Gdan!
t�7mect Crp�q� tnd Oatalo provloeul m1ai�Mu
•dr �monnt ot tun u�ai.ad wi�h DuGapou employ�u �nd U»ir fatllltet pald ro Ma
Tmrn� of Ciuin�«y A�u. ud a'NtD�,
�d�a pvm� ol builnatq ia rhe Toweu of d�riojton, AJaa, r�d Wliltby a�wclued wl�h
D.ru„poa eraoloyw wa tAeir Gmiva.
Mnddyd 3at(ta aa! FulUtlr
(Ai'd� IOOnOf010 impku on munidp�l wrvkn md t.riUtia lnciudfa� nenaila�
hcWtlM� Propmty valum� end Aed�h and uhcy reivku In rheTown ot Plckmfo� �nd ihe
[le�lan of DurLen te�u)tiao fmm the oa�oin� opa�don o(Ihe Picketl7t� A�nd S
NWooi, tde non•nttut o( Walcetin� A. uid ILt d�cammiutooind of the Plcltetity
tKUiry,
(B�� �notnlc imp�eq an usunieipil tmieu +od fuilidee ia ihe Town of Cluin jca�
+iad tEa Re�fon af Du:Aun cmalHna from �ho on�oin� apvuia of Dulla{ton Nucieu
a,s.
Odur Imp+cu may bc identilted throu�hout the cmu+e of tAe �roay.
�
A coasnitant wld be mquiced ro ondr.akc Qle fcuey. ,1 douilW work�lu wi0 be
P�� � P� of �6e eoav�a.
'lhe OFL`I pfopet m�oa�tt w01 be Pat 0'Bdai.
'Ifia tponar w�W 6e 71�
�
Tha roport �h�l bn t(ndiz�d �ad daiivaed to Om+uto HyC�+o an J�nwuy I S� t999.
, .
`'
f
�`
fF;OM : JACK GARTLEY COPSU.TI�IG
�
F0.K Iq. : 9CI5 b6ei ;9:2� Jon. IB 1999 Q9: 2i11 Pl0
fng
Attachmenl 3
�STIMATED TIME TO BE 3PE�T ON PROJECT
BY INDEPENDENT CONSULTANT
It is anHcipated that Ihe workload of Ihe independenl consullant would be
allocated as follows�
1. Gensral Meetfnas with Main Cansuitant Hoated bv Ontario Hvdro
- actual attendance at meelings
- estimated preparafion time
2. Meetinas with Town Council
8.0 days
8.0 davs
16.0 days
- actual atlendance at meetings (three times at ane hour each) 0.5 days
- estimated preparalion Gme 3,0 davs
�.5 days
�. Discusslons with Representatfves from Ontario Hvdro,
Clarinqton. and Durfiam, it rcquired
- items o( mulual inlerest a�d concern related lo lhe progress
of the Study 1.0 day
4. Research bv Independent Consultant
- review and comment cn vrorkplan of main consultant
- revlew and commenl on documenlation provided by
Ontario Hydro (historic trecking of cosls and expenses
on economic benefits to host municipalities)
- olher research (revlew olher reporls made available
by Ontario Hydro, e g., annual reports, news releases, etc.
2.0 days
3.0 days
4 5 davs
9.5 days
Total 30.0 days
j; ,
�
; RI �, J�:K CfRiL6f C0�5l.�TI1JG FK�t ID. : 905 b6e .923 lan. l8 1949 09i;?it1 PII
110
Atlachment 4
ESTIMATED COSTS OF HIRINd JACK GARTLEY OF JACK GARTLEY
CONSULTIN(i TO UN�ERTAKE THE TA9K OF AN INDEPENDENT
CONSULTANT FOR THE ECONOMIC IMPACT STUDY
Cost af preparing for and attending meelinp9 uf Council and Ihose
of the main consultanl hired by Onta �o Hydro, as required $140lhour
Cost af research needed to review documentation provided by
Ontar(o Hydro, mein consultanl, and others, as required $ 65lhour
Cost of word processing, faxes, telephones, and traveling, as
requlred Adual cost
It is anticipated that Jack Gartley would be employed approximately 30 man
days on this project over Ihe length of the Study period of three months. This
would consist of 19.5 man days oxpended on preparing for and allendfng
meetings and 10.5 man days expended on research and related matters.
in tolal, it Is estimated Ihat the cost of employing Jack Gartley on this projed
could range irom $16,000 lo 520,000, depending on accuracy of estimales of
numbers oi meetings, etc.
�
�:
,, -
FFOM : JACK GfRT�EY COfFJATItIG ' Fk�f �q. :?OS ee6 ;?» Jan. le t9?9 0g:3�i PI?
. .f .i 1
Attachment 5
JACK GARTLEY CONSULTING IS A SOLE PROPRIETORSHIP
THAT IS AN UNINCORPORATEb BUSINESS
WHICH IS OWNED BY JqCK GARTLEY
Professional Exoertence:
Approximalely 30 years at a seniof capacity employed by ihe Regional
Municipatlty of Durham as Commissioner of Finance and Treasurer (24 years)
and Ihe Ministry of Treasury, Economics and Inlergovemmenlal AHairs (6 years),
Sfnce retirement (rom Ihe Region in July 31, 1997, worked as a consultant to the
Finance Departmenl of the Town of Pickering periotlically belween January 1998
and November 1990.
rofesFtonal Quaiifications:
Certified Menagement Accounlant (CMA)
Designatinn from the Assocfatlon of Munfcipal Clerks and Treasurers of Onlario
(AMCT)
Certificate (ram Ihe Sociely of Management Accounlanle of Onlario --
Management Development Course dealing with organizatfonal behaviour,
general management, and economics
Profossional Membershias:
Member AMO (Associallon of Municipalities of Onlano) Fiscal Policy Commitlee
(1982-1991)
Membef AMO Sub-Committee on Lot Leviee and Front•end Financinp (1983-
1989)
Member AMO Sub-Committee on Unconditional Granls (1992-1988)
Member AMO Response Team on SARC Report "TronsiUons"
Member AMO Response Team on PMSSR (Report of the Provincial/Municipal
Sor,ial Services Review)
Member of AMO Board of Directors as Chairman of the Municipal Finance
Officers Association of Onlnrio (1985-1989)
Elected to AMO 8oard of Directors in 1989, 1990, and 1991
I �
j.
�.
FppM i JNCK GARi1,EY i.OfSLITIfIG F� Iq. : 9k15 EG6.5?s� Jan. t8 l993 63;JpF11 pl;
�iLL
Summarv of Relavant Expe�ienco�
Wttile with Ihe Reglon of Durham, Mr. Garlley supervised Ihe preparation of
wrilten submissions and made numeroua oral presentations lo thn
representatives ot the two major Unfled States' bond rating houses that
eventually resulled in the Regien and ils constituent area municipalities being
awarded a TriDle A credit raHna. This raNng has been suslained from 1989 lo
the present lfine. Mr. Garlley actively coordinaled with staf( and counci�
members a re-engineering pro�ect for the Corporation Ihat took a fresh look at
how services to ils taxpayers were delivered. This resulted in significant sevings
in costs w(thout lowering the level oi services (1990 and 1997).
1Nhile employed with lhe Ontario Ministry of Treasury, Economics and
Inte�govemmental Affairs, Mr. Gartley vras responsible for Ihe Mini�lry's fleltl
program providing advice and assistance to Municipal Treasurers, Auditors, and
Councilors on all areas of municipal ftnancial management. One of his specific
responaibilities was lo assist in lhia setup of new Regions in Ihe early 1970's.
Another responsibflily was to act as the initiating force behind the `Locat
Governme�t Managemenl ProJect' sponsored by the Province and involving Ihe
School of Businesa at Quean's University and Project Municipalitfes. Designed
to develop netler municipal management, lhis project was Implemented in the
Regional Municipalily oi Niagara and the Ciqes of London, St. Catharines, and
Odavra.
While employed as a consullant with the Finance Department for Ihe 7ovm of
Pickering, Mr. Gartley worked on a number of projects for Mr. G A. Palerson,
Treasurer. These prajects included an impact study on Ihe loss in PIL payments
lo lhe Town from Ontario Hydro (paid lo the Region In 1998) and a financial
contral policy aHecling ell deparlmenls of Ihe Town, which is still In progress.
.;
,.. , • .
w, � �, �- � � �
y ��.� . . -.. .. .� � - : � . ' .. �
:,. . � .k7r �` ��. . . . .'.' ...! -" !..:: � �..: ..' . _..,. ..